Hobbit or Game of Thrones?

[Hathor]

Game of Thrones for me.

The Hobbit reminded me of something I saw a few years ago.... please spare us the Titanic style flute music and the tearful speeches which signal the end of the movie.

Anybody got any views on this?

[OakAshandThorn]

I didn't get to see The Hobbit (yet ;) ), but I have read the book many times over, and it just gets better and better each time I read it. I'm a big fan of JRR Tolkien :).
I personally adore the Irish whistle music in Peter Jackson's version of The Lord of the Rings movies - I could listen to Sir James Galway all day and never get bored ;).
To be honest, I get a bit teary-eyed at the end of the movies and sometimes when I finish of one Tolkien's books.

[FishyFolk]

Whats in my pocket?

[luresalive]

The Hobbit .. without a doubt, game of thrones is a poor pretender..

[JonnyP]

Tolkien fan here too. I saw the Hobbit film a couple of weeks or so ago. Its very good as a film but its not the book.
I do not know Game of thrones

[NS40]

I must admit to really enjoying both but Game of Thrones is addictive. Having watched a couple of series, I'm now going to start on the books.

[redbranchwarrior]

Hobbit

[AL...]

Read all the Game of Thrones books they are fantastic.
TV program is good but it dont have near the buget that The Hobbit has (Havent seen that yet)

Cheers
AL

[OakAshandThorn]

Tolkien fan here too. I saw the Hobbit film a couple of weeks or so ago. Its very good as a film but its not the book.
I do not know Game of thrones
That's what I thought...Peter Jackson is excellent, but he's certainly not Tolkien himself ;).

[BushcraftJustin]

Yep... definately Hobbit!

[rosseveritt]

JRR for me. First read the books when I was 11 and have read them many times since. :)