PDA

View Full Version : Preferred boot (or other) outsole brand.



chris_leech
24-11-2013, 12:54 PM
Just curious as to how much outsole make, factors into your choosing of boots. I never personally put any thought into it as my first three pairs of what I would call proper boots (2xkarrimors and 1xmeindhl) all had vibram soles but my latest pair of salomans with their 'contagrip' soles are rubbish in comparison. Weather it be on wet rock, mud or snow/ice. TBH they would have been retired long ago if they weren't soo comfortable.

Silverback
24-11-2013, 02:04 PM
Love my Meindls....the Vibram sole is excellent.

Had several pairs (3) of Salomons and they just werent up to the job (I was MRT/SAR) and i would always return to the Meindl....I wear a pair of UK Issue extreme cold weather boots for work they have an excellent Vibram sole and I now have a pair of Altberg Field and Fell for playing and so far the Skywalk sole is impressing me....

Fraser
25-11-2013, 07:06 AM
Just curious as to how much outsole make, factors into you choosing of boots. I never personally put any thought into it as my first three pairs of what I would call proper boots (2xkarrimors and 1xmeindhl) all had vibrab soles but my latest pair of salomans with their 'contagrip' soles are rubbish in comparison. Weather it be on wet rock, mud or snow/ice. TBH they would have been retired long ago if they weren't soo comfortable.
Before my Meindls I had the truely awful (yet very comfortable and would also have been retired ages ago if it wasnt for the comfort) Jack Pyke Countryman boots. I'm not sure what sole was on the Jack Pykes but the Meindls feel a lot more ... sure footed.

jus_young
25-11-2013, 09:30 PM
Even the Vibram soles can be different between brands. I have had a few different makes that utilise the Vibram footprint but found my current Merrells to be the best so far.

Martin
26-11-2013, 08:32 AM
For a while, I was a convert to Salomon. However, I have found the quality and customer service from this company to be so bad that I will never buy any of their products again. Goretex liners that leak, eyelets that snap and quick tie laces that come untied!! Their solution??? Buy a repair kit from us!!!

I have now reverted to my Meindls

Salomon = Avoid like the plague

Martin

David_JAFO
26-11-2013, 12:33 PM
hello,
Kinda off topic. Firstly 'Salomon' yes I agree Martin & Meindls are a good brand. A mate of mine Ex-Services he imported Soviet Military issue thick rubber soles for a pair of boots he was repairing for going fishing. He has used pairs of Russian Army issue boots in the past. He does leather/shoe repair as a side line. Not only did the thick rubber soles keep out sharp objects but insulated his feet in the water. He now has a number of repairs on other boots by customers using the Soviet issue rubber soles. He say's they're hard wearing to 'boot' (pardon the pun) :wink:.
Regards
David

chris_leech
26-11-2013, 08:35 PM
Not much love for salomons it seems. Mine are now reserved for summer/causal use. In my local (council managed)woods there are some 'off trail' routes that run along by a stream. These are quite treacherous when the stream swells and the salomons just aren't up to the job and I don't fancy going for a swim.

Silverback
26-11-2013, 09:45 PM
I used a pair of Salomons during the 2007 flood rescues in S Yorks...a month later they started to fall apart...that may have had more to do with the water though ;)

Midge_Fodder
23-02-2014, 05:17 PM
I like my vibram. Had a pair of brasher fellmaster gtx for a while, I didn't even get a year out of them. To be honest I don't think I even done 200 miles before they were needing a resole. I only got them as my last pair of Lowas were too heavy for the summer, but even still £100 plus boots should get mileage out of them than that.

OakAshandThorn
23-02-2014, 06:08 PM
My winter boots are Sorels from the late 1960s with many miles to their name, and they're still going strong...only need to recondition the leather with LL Bean Boot Guard every now and then.
For the rest of the year, my Timberland Mt. Maddsen Earthkeepers have proven their worth and more...SO much better than the cr** el-cheapo Hi-Tec boots I used to wear. Most folks I know prefer their Timberlands to just about anything else on the US market.

flounder_al
23-02-2014, 06:52 PM
I have a pair of Hi-Tec Magnum Cobras that I use. Excellent comfy boots that have never failed me yet. I used to wear DMS boots a lot in the forces and they nearly crippled me.

Midge_Fodder
23-02-2014, 06:59 PM
Magnums always split across the ball of the foot on me.

flounder_al
23-02-2014, 07:02 PM
Touch wood they've been ok for me lol

Midge_Fodder
23-02-2014, 07:05 PM
I think it's hard to measure as no one walks the same. The joke my mam has is she can spot my walk from 100 paces lol. Some people swear by them magnums others hate them